Provincial Education Property Tax Reform

Subject Governance
Year 2024
Status Adopted - Active
Sponsor - Mover
St. Albert, City of
Sponsor - Seconder
Penhold, Town of
Active Clauses

IT IS THEREFORE RESOLVED THAT Alberta Municipalities advocate to the Government of Alberta to action the Minister of Municipal Affairs’ mandate letter from the Premier, to review the provincial education property tax to assist municipalities with retaining more funding for local priorities, with the outcome being that municipalities receive provincial funding for municipal infrastructure equal to or greater than what is collectively requisitioned in provincial education property tax on an annual basis for the Government of Alberta. 

Whereas Clauses

WHEREAS local public infrastructure such as transportation, water/wastewater utilities, stormwater management, and other local priorities are vital to the sustainability of municipalities and the quality of life for Albertans such as recreation and community facilities; 

WHEREAS municipalities across Alberta have highlighted the need for increased municipal infrastructure funding and alternative financing mechanisms and policies to maintain existing infrastructure, build new infrastructure, and support community growth, through the adoption of several associated resolutions at the 2023 Alberta Municipalities Convention; 

WHEREAS provincial revenue-sharing with municipalities does not meet the need for local public infrastructure investment, as it has decreased from $420 per Albertan in 2011 to $186 in 2024, while municipalities face increasing fiscal pressures related to population growth and high inflation-driven construction costs (1);

(1) Alberta Municipalities – Preliminary Analysis on Alberta’s 2024 Budget, pg. 5 - https://www.abmunis.ca/system/files/2024- 03/ABmunis%20Preliminary%20Analysis%20on%20Alberta%27s%202024%20Budget.pdf 

WHEREAS the Government of Alberta’s 2024-27 Fiscal Plan expects that municipalities will collect over $2.7 billion in provincial education property tax in 2024 on behalf of the province, and predicts this figure will grow by 4.3% a year to $3 billion in 2026-272 (2); 

(2) Government of Alberta’s 2024-27 Fiscal Plan, Page 63 - https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/23c82502-fd11-45c6-861f99381fffc748/resource/3782cc8f-fdc4-4704- 9c50-07fc36e05722/download/budget-2024-fiscal-plan-2024-27.pdf 

WHEREAS on behalf of the Government of Alberta, municipalities collect $1 billion more for provincial revenue via the provincial education property tax than what they receive in total provincial funding for municipal infrastructure via the Local Government Fiscal Framework (LGFF), competitive grant programs, and other one-time capital investments; and 

WHEREAS the 2023 mandate letter for the Minister of Municipal Affairs directs the ministry to review the feasibility of amending the provincial education property tax to assist municipalities with retaining more funding for local priorities. 

Resolution Background

The collection of the provincial education property tax by municipalities in its current form was established by the Government of Alberta in 1994. Based on equalized assessment value, the province calculates each year the amount of provincial education property taxes that a municipality must transfer to the Government of Alberta. Municipalities are subsequently responsible to calculate the amount of provincial education property taxes to be charged to each property based on their assessed property values. As the provincial education property tax is typically billed to residents in combination with their municipal property taxes, residents may be unaware that approximately 30% of their property tax bill is submitted to the province – it is a reasonable expectation that local property taxes billed by a municipality will fund the services and infrastructure needs within their local community. 

The Government of Alberta’s 2024-27 Fiscal Plan notes that municipalities are expected to collect $2.7 billion worth of provincial education property tax in 2024-25, and that this revenue will grow by 4.4% per year to $3 billion in 2026-27. (1)

(1) Government of Alberta’s 2024-27 Fiscal Plan, Page 63 - https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/23c82502-fd11-45c6-861f99381fffc748/resource/3782cc8f-fdc4-4704- 9c50-07fc36e05722/download/budget-2024-fiscal-plan-2024-27.pdf 

As the provincial education property tax is tied directly to property assessment values, growth in assessment and new development means that growing municipalities have seen their associated tax requisition increase in 2024 despite a provincial freeze on the tax rate. This increase is especially tangible for municipalities witnessing exceptional growth in development and assessment values, which in effect causes them to become victims of their own success as their provincial education property tax rates increase along with their growth in assessed property values. 

The 2023 Mandate Letter for the Ministry of Municipal Affairs directed the Minister to “review the feasibility of amending the provincial education property tax to assist municipalities with retaining more funding for local priorities.” At the 2024 Alberta Municipalities Spring Municipal Leaders Caucus, Premier Danielle Smith noted that the Province will provide more public infrastructure funding to municipalities in 2024 – approximately $3.6 billion total – than what municipalities collect in Education Property Tax, if all infrastructure spending is included in addition to LGFF allocations. Analysis by Alberta Municipalities found this assertion is accurate if inclusive of federal funding for local infrastructure allocated by the province and spending on provincially-owned highways and bridges; due to these funding allocations either being dissociated from provincial revenues and spending, or from funding municipally owned and operated infrastructure, a more accurate figure of $1.73 billion is being spent on local infrastructure, which is $1 billion less than what municipalities will collect in provincial education property tax in 2024. (2)

(2)  Alberta Municipalities – Breaking Down Alberta’s Capital Support for Municipalities in 2024. https://www.abmunis.ca/news/breaking-down-albertas-capital-support-municipalities-2024  

Should the Government of Alberta reform the provincial education property tax and/or revenue sharing mechanisms with municipalities to be equal to or greater than what they collect in education property tax, the additional $1 billion in funding would bridge the municipal infrastructure funding gap that exists when current LGFF Capital funding compared with historical funding for municipal public infrastructure. (3)

 (3) Alberta Municipalities: Let’s Talk About Infrastructure - https://www.abmunis.ca/advocacy- resources/infrastructure/lets-talkabout-infrastructure 

Reforming the education property tax in this manner would provide municipalities with the needed fiscal capacity to maintain and build infrastructure to support the quality of life Albertans expect from their local and provincial governments. 

There may be some instances across Alberta Municipalities’ membership base where individual municipalities currently receive more funding in provincial grants than what they collect in provincial education property tax. The active resolution clause has been worded to consider this factor, as the intent is not to lead to decreased funding for any municipality, but to be equal or greater than what they are individually requisitioned in provincial education property tax. 

Alberta Municipalities notes

Over the years, members have approved numerous resolutions on the issue of provincial property taxes with the most recent resolution in 2020, which called for the Government of Alberta to take over responsibility for the collection of provincial property taxes. The Government of Alberta’s response was that the current system provides for the most efficient method of collecting provincial property taxes. Through the development of the Local Government Fiscal Framework Capital program, ABmunis also highlighted and advocated against the growing gap between provincial property taxes and provincial capital funding provided to municipalities.  

Since the release of the Premier’s 2023 mandate letter, ABmunis has sought regular updates from ministers on the government’s progress and to date has been informed that the review is still under work. If this resolution is passed, it will be forwarded to the Government of Alberta for response. Further advocacy would be recommended to ABmunis’ Board by the Municipal Governance Committee within the context of related priorities and positions.